Melodie Robinson: 'It's still reasonably difficult for women in sports broadcasting'

Two-time Rugby World Cup winner and Japan 2019 commentator Melodie Robinson discusses the challenges she faced when starting life as a sports journalist.

Melodie Robinson admits life on the road could get fairly lonely when she began her career as a sports journalist over two decades ago.

Robinson was drawn to the profession having completed an assignment on women’s sport at university, and come to the conclusion that coverage was almost non-existent.

She felt that the best way to change that was by becoming a reporter herself. Robinson subsequently signed up to a post-graduate journalism course, although her friends weren’t initially confident that she could become a female Keith Quinn.

“He [Quinn] was the man in New Zealand. I think my mates laughed at me because they were like ‘Whatever, a chick can’t do that’,” she remembered. 

“But I think playing rugby helped that along a little bit and I guess I got a couple of opportunities from a couple of bosses, so a bit of luck back then too. 

'You've got to be really confident'

“It’s been lovely, it’s been great and now I’ve got a new role at TVNZ where I’m giving other women opportunities as well.”

It’s fair to say Robinson was more than just ‘a player’. As a two-time Rugby World Cup winner with the Black Ferns, who also represented New Zealand at sevens, the 46-year-old clearly knows what she is talking about.

Her achievements in broadcasting were recognised earlier this year when she was immortalised as a Barbie doll as part of the ‘Shero’ series. But at the start of her career she was well aware that she was the only woman on the New Zealand rugby media circuit.

“There weren’t hardly any women on the road so I’d be travelling every weekend and you’re always with the guys,” Robinson explained. 

“So, that gets quite lonely and you’ve got to be really confident just to hang out with people and make an effort to ring them and say ‘I’m coming out with you’. So you force yourself on them. 

“A lot of people were very resistant to it, I had quite a few comments thrown at me over the years and I think it still is reasonably difficult for women to be normalised in sports broadcasting.” 

Robinson is glad to note that the situation is getting better. She has been part of the Rugby World Cup 2019 broadcasting team on the world feed and in her role as General Manager, Sport and Events, at TVNZ has also given Black Fern Kristina Sue an opportunity in the pundit’s chair.

“It’s great to see Danielle Waterman and Maggie Alphonsi as part of ITV as well,” Robinson added. 

“It’s starting to change and I just think it’s good because rugby’s not just for men, it’s not just for the fans, it’s for women and young girls who are playing in massive numbers as well. 

Reaching out to new audiences

“So, it’s just exciting to see that evolution.”

In Japan, Robinson has formed a popular commentary team alongside Sean Maloney and Andrew Mehrtens, which was bolstered by Eddie Butler for the quarter-finals.

The 46-year-old has known Mehrtens since childhood in Christchurch and worked with Maloney on the HSBC World Rugby Sevens Series. Welshman Butler was integrated into the fold during karaoke sessions in Oita.

Robinson admits most of the group’s preparation for matches is done “by osmosis” as at least a quarter of their conversations concern rugby. 

However, that discounts the work Robinson does chatting to former team-mates, coaches, players and other journalists to bring viewers and listeners the stories behind the names on the teamsheet.

“When you have a huge audience like we have with this Rugby World Cup, you want to cater to everybody who’s watching – they’re not all rugby experts,” Robinson explained.

“They might not be specific rugby statistics but there’s a wider entertainment part of it. So it helps them to know who those players are and humanises them a bit, and explains the rules to people who get confused.”

RWC 2019 has introduced rugby to a whole new audience in Asia and Robinson has been impressed with the way that the Japanese public has got behind the tournament.

“It’s the impact,” she said. “The fact that mums and dads bring all of their family and their kids down to the fanzones and they just hang out there right to the last whistle of the game and it’s really late but they’re still having a great time and talking to everybody. 

“So, it’s really quite different – the food’s good too!”

US Women's Eagles player Tess Feury (centre)
Women's Feature News Women in Rugby
Women's Eagles star nursing the sick in New Jersey
We highlight more members of the rugby family working tirelessly to help people during the COVID-19 pandemic, including Women's Eagles player Tess Feury.
Guatemala v El Salvador
Women's Feature News Women in Rugby
Guatemala and El Salvador make history
The women's teams of Guatemala and El Salvador played their first international match earlier this month, breaking new ground in their respective countries.
Rugby Europe Trophy 2020: Germany v Switzerland
Men's Feature News Tournament News Women in Rugby
Swiss build for a sustainable future
Rugby Suisse CEO Veronika Muehlhofer says there is more to the success of rugby in the country than a record World Rugby Men’s Ranking of 28th.
Filoi Eneliko
Olympics Women's Feature News GIR Olympic Qualifying Tournament News Women in Rugby
Eneliko standing up for women in the Pacific
Former Samoa sevens player Filoi Eneliko discusses the reasons behind her decision to participate in the inaugural Women's Sport Leadership Academy for High Performance Coaches.
Nathalie Amiel - HOF 1
Women's Feature News Hall of Fame Tournament News Women in Rugby
Nathalie Amiel: The 'country girl' turned Hall of Fame inductee
Former France international and World Rugby Hall of Fame inductee Nathalie Amiel, who won 56 caps and experienced five Rugby World Cups as a player and a coach, discusses her incredible career in the game.
World Rugby logo
Media release Women's News Women in Rugby
World Rugby extends Women’s Executive Leadership Scholarships programme after global success
Ahead of International Women’s Day, World Rugby has announced an extension of its Women’s Executive Leadership Scholarship programme.
Aimee Barrett-Theron
Women's Feature News Tournament News Women in Rugby
Barrett-Theron 'excited for women's rugby' following Euro trip'
South African referee Aimee Barrett-Theron caught up with World Rugby following her recent experience in the Women's Six Nations.
Papua New Guinea v Tonga - RWC 2021 qualifier
Women's News Tournament News Women in Rugby
Tonga keep RWC 2021 dream alive
Tonga battled past Papua New Guinea to set up a play-off with Samoa for a place in the Rugby World Cup 2021 repechage.
Black Ferns Development XV v Papua New Guinea
Women's Feature News Tournament News Women in Rugby
Proud Cassowaries ready for historic test
Papua New Guinea are preparing to face Tonga in a Rugby World Cup 2021 qualifier – the first women's test to be played in the country – and they have a new nickname to mark the occasion.
Berta García coaching
Women's Feature News Women in Rugby
García using experience to grow Spanish rugby
Former Spain international Berta García talks to World Rugby about her coaching ambitions and hopes for the women's game in her homeland.